By: Roan Szucs
Edited by: Constanza Leautaud Grajales
As the War in Ukraine trots on with no feasible resolution in sight, Ukrainians continue to seek refuge in surrounding states. This inflicts an unprecedented strain onto the sociopolitical and economic systems of those accepting the most refugees, provoking both polarization and concerning degrees of protectionism. The war is causing states accepting the most refugees to lean toward hate; not toward those behind the war, but the refugees fleeing.
Out of the 5.8 million refugees from Ukraine reported in Europe, Poland alone has accepted over 959 000. The sociopolitical ecosystem in Poland is beginning to respond to the mass entry of those seeking refuge, with a survey released in August displaying that the number of Poles who support allowing refugees from Ukraine has fallen to 69% from 91% just after the war started… a quarter are against, compared to just 4% in early 2022.
Evidently, there is a descent of support for refugee allowance among the Polish citizenry, with social services being exhausted, labour markets overwhelmed, and more complications on the horizon. As sociopolitical institutions continue to become more overwhelmed, dropping support amongst the Poles began a shift toward more hate-based sentiments. These sentiments have and continue to be weaponized by various political leaders, with internal polarization, partisanship, and protectionist sentiment within Poland following suit. Rafal Pankowski, the head of “Never Again”, a Polish anti-racism organization, has expressed that for the majority of the war, Polish support for Ukrainian refugees was felt across the political spectrum… However, Pankowski has been surprised by a shift in rhetoric over recent months among the right-wing parties to include anti-Ukrainian sentiments.
The mass acceptance of refugees into Poland is beginning to see, as displayed above, not a concern for an overwhelmed socio-political infrastructure (although this is part of the manifestation), but an advancing anti-Ukrainian rhetoric amongst the Poles.
Predictably, this hateful rhetoric sparked by Russian invasion was successfully weaponized by incumbent and oppositional political parties, increasing the grounds for partisanship, intensifying polarization, creating possibly the most fertile breeding ground for Polish protectionism in decades, manifesting in an overall increase in hate towards Ukrainians seeking asylum.
To combat these hateful sentiments, complications that accompany immigration en masse into any state must be addressed; with the amplification of nationalist-protectionist disdain towards Ukrainians being stopped in its tracks to avoid further division in Poland.
For mass-refugee-accepting states such as Poland to address their growing protectionist-disdain for Ukrainians, there first must be clarity on the sociopolitical areas most affected by the entry of refugees. The most notable areas in need of addressing include protectionist attitudes spread through disinformation; labour market control; language barriers; child support and accommodation; and housing.
Addressing concerns of protectionist attitudes spread through disinformation, multinational professional services network Deloitte proposes the combat of disinformation campaigns through preparing set information materials for all key stakeholders, as well as conducting information campaigns concerning the benefits of refugee integration for the Polish general public. With disinformation combatted effectively, the Poles can tackle matters of labour market control (through federal collaboration with businesses for effective onboarding), language barriers (by the creation of a support program through which immigrants can learn Polish), child support (providing access to preschool and school for refugee children), and housing (accelerating the building construction process to increase the availability of housing).
When the disinformation-fueled anti-Ukrainian sentiments within states such as Poland are addressed (through information campaigns or otherwise), a more productive environment is created to tackle the sociopolitical implications of accepting refugees en masse.
With disinformation fueling protectionism immobilized, the solutions for sociopolitical issues (labour market control, language barriers, child support, and housing) stemming from wartime migration can be addressed through logical means, benefiting both the host-state, and the refugees entering.
Adler, N. (2023, September 27). Anti-migrant rhetoric dominates politics in Poland ahead of October vote. Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/9/27/anti-migrant-rhetoric-dominates-politics-in-poland-ahead-of-october-vote
Charlish, A., & Strzelecki, M. (2023, September 19). Analysis: Poland’s pis faces far-right challenge over Ukraine support. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/polands-pis-faces-far-right-challenge-over-ukraine-support-2023-09-19/#:~:text=SHIFTING%20VIEWS,just%204%25%20in%20early%202022.
Opperational Data Portal. (2023, October 11). Ukraine Refugee Situation. https://data.unhcr.org/en/situations/ukraine
Wodzicki, M., Pichola, I., & Patorska, J. (2022, October). Refugees from Ukraine in Poland: Challenges and potential for integration. Deloitte US | Audit, Consulting, Advisory, and Tax Services. https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/pl/Documents/Reports/pl_ENG_Report_Refugees_from_Ukraine_in_Poland.pdf
Silar. (2022). Ukrainian refugees offered meals, clothes, shelter in Kraków. Wikimedia Commons. Retrieved October 2023, from https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:02022_0202-001_Ukrainian_refugees_offered_meals,_clothes,_shelter_in_Krak%C3%B3w.jpg.